Who is guarding the Ofsted guard?

7 Jul 23

Teachers are questioning the usefulness and effectiveness of Ofsted inspections. After the suicide of a headteacher, something needs to change, says a senior teacher.


While we have yet to experience an Ofsted visit, like many schools we are awaiting our first call post-Covid. We have seen local schools go through the process and have heard a range of stories around their experiences.

Despite not yet receiving a visit from His Majesty’s inspectorate, I can still observe the waves being made across the profession. I recently saw a joke on Twitter, which broadly went something like this…

“Is anybody else old enough to remember when you rang up a supply agency and they had teachers ready and available that day?”

Teacher recruitment worries me immensely. Despite our school’s location, flanked by universities and teaching colleges, even we are beginning to see a drop in applications. While we are still in the fortunate position where we can interview a range of strong applicants, I know other schools are not so lucky.

I remember the first job I ever applied for (and didn’t receive an invitation to interview). I rang looking for feedback. I was told my application was strong. However, there had been 83 applications, which had been whittled down to 22 interviewees (all for one post). I imagine there are very few schools that would not be envious of this type of return now.

The children still make us smile as much as they always have, colleagues laugh and cry with us as they always have. So, what has changed over the 10 years since my first job application? As Dr Mary Bousted, joint general secretary of the National Education Union, points out from survey results, one factor is “the pernicious effects of a punitive and deeply flawed inspection system”.

Ofsted aims to be a force for improvement, but I have yet to be connected with, engaged with or worked closely with the organisation. Ofsted and the profession, as a whole, need to talk

While studying for my National Professional Qualification in Leadership through the National College, I was taught the importance of leading improvement by connecting, engaging and working closely with staff. Ofsted aims to be a force for improvement, but I have yet to be connected with, engaged with or worked closely with the organisation.

Ofsted and the profession, as a whole, need to talk.

There has not been enough work or research for me to suggest an alternative to the current model. Is this indicative of an organisation that doesn’t want to change? I think most education staff understand the need for Ofsted and would support it through a period of reformation where views and ideas are shared and not dictated.

At my own (special) primary school we have been talking about the ineffectiveness of the one-size-fits-all inspection that we were included within for many years. Even now, with the latest Ofsted reforms, this has yet to be addressed or even discussed.

Speaking to colleagues in other schools, some have described the process being broadly positive. Yet even they question the usefulness and effectiveness of current inspections. Some questioned whether the build-up was worse than the visit itself. This leads me to finish with two questions. Is Ofsted and the associated dread something we ‘do’ to each other, feeding off the urban legends and horror stories passed around at training events? Or has Ofsted developed such a culture of fear that it is simply too late for half-hearted reform? Regardless, something needs to change.

Our SECRET TEACHER is a senior leader in a special primary school and a member of the National Education Union

Image credit | Shutterstock

Did you enjoy this article?